Written by the MTDFix Editorial Team · Reviewed by Shamayun Chowdhury, ACMA, Senior Accountant · Published: 22 November 2026 · Last reviewed: November 2026 · Applies to the 2026/27 tax year

Quick Answer
HMRC has issued several warnings that some umbrella companies run tax avoidance schemes, paying part of your wages as untaxed “loans” or other payments. Warning signs include take-home pay that seems too high, money arriving outside your payslip and being moved between umbrellas. If you are caught up in one, you can end up owing the tax yourself.

A bigger take-home sounds like a good deal, until a letter from HMRC arrives asking for thousands of pounds in unpaid tax. That is the risk behind every HMRC umbrella company warning. HMRC has published several of them because some umbrella companies keep workers’ pay looking normal on the surface while paying part of it in ways that dodge Income Tax and National Insurance.

This guide brings HMRC’s warnings together for agency workers and contractors: twelve warning signs, a pay test, a payslip check and what to do if you are in a scheme or receive an HMRC letter.

Key points
  • HMRC never approves umbrella companies or tax avoidance schemes, whatever a company claims.
  • Pay labelled as a loan, annuity or bonus for your work is still taxable employment income.
  • If more money reaches your bank than your payslip’s net pay, something is wrong.
  • You can check what your employer reports to HMRC in your personal tax account.
  • If you are in a scheme, leaving early and contacting HMRC usually keeps interest and penalties lower.

What Is the HMRC Umbrella Company Warning?

HMRC publishes “Spotlights”, which are public warnings about tax avoidance it has seen. When people search for an HMRC umbrella company warning, these are usually what they mean. Three of them deal with umbrella companies:

WarningWho it is forMain message
Spotlight 60Agency workers and contractorsSome umbrellas pay wages in disguised, untaxed forms; most of these schemes do not work
Spotlight 71Workers moved between umbrellasMoving workers between companies is used to hide avoidance from HMRC
Spotlight 64Employment agenciesAgencies should check the umbrellas in their supply chains

About 700,000 people work through umbrella companies, according to HMRC’s umbrella company market policy paper. Most umbrellas are compliant, and working through one is perfectly legal. The warnings are about the minority that are not. HMRC is clear on one point: it “never approves avoidance schemes or the compliance of any umbrella companies”, so any claim of HMRC approval is itself a warning sign.

If you want to understand how a normal umbrella company works first, read Eternity Accountants’ guide to what an umbrella company is.

How Umbrella Company Tax Avoidance Works

A compliant umbrella runs all your pay through PAYE. Income Tax and National Insurance are deducted, and the payslip matches what reaches your bank. A non-compliant one puts only part through payroll, often close to the minimum wage, and pays the rest separately.

That separate money is given a label such as a loan, an advance, an annuity, a bonus, a share of profits or a grant. The idea is that it is not salary, so no tax is due. This is known as disguised remuneration. HMRC’s position, set out in Spotlight 60, is that any payment for your work is employment income, whatever it is called and however it is paid.

Mini umbrella company (MUC) fraud

A related problem is mini umbrella company fraud. Workers are spread across many small, short-lived companies, often run by people abroad, to claim small-employer reliefs and then close before paying the tax. HMRC’s Spotlight 64 warns agencies about these supply chains. As a worker, you may notice it as frequent changes of employer name with little explanation.

12 HMRC Umbrella Company Warning Signs

Drawing together Spotlight 60, Spotlight 71 and HMRC’s leaflet Spot the signs, these are the signs HMRC tells workers to look out for.

  1. A promised take-home percentage, such as “keep 80% of your pay”.
  2. Pay split into two or more payments, with only one shown on your payslip.
  3. Payments described as loans, annuities, bonuses or shares instead of wages.
  4. More money in your bank than the net pay on your payslip. HMRC says this “cannot be correct”.
  5. Extra agreements to sign, such as a loan or annuity agreement, or “standard” and “enhanced” pay options.
  6. A short, vague or missing contract, or being asked to sign more than one employment contract.
  7. High fees, or fees close to the tax and National Insurance you would expect to pay. Spotlight 60 reports that non-compliant umbrellas may keep around 15% to 22% of the invoice value. That is HMRC’s warning figure, not a normal or acceptable fee for a compliant umbrella.
  8. An overseas base, such as the Isle of Man or Channel Islands, even if the company has a UK phone number.
  9. Being moved to a new umbrella or payroll at short notice, with a new employer name, PAYE reference or payment method. HMRC notes that it does not limit how many employees a company can have.
  10. Switching to paper payslips, or losing access to your old payslips online.
  11. Being referred by a comparison or broker website that may be linked to the promoter.
  12. Being told not to contact HMRC, or being offered “free help” to deal with HMRC for you.

These signs do not on their own prove that an umbrella is running a scheme. But if several appear together, treat it as a serious HMRC umbrella company warning: ask for a full breakdown of your pay and get independent advice before carrying on.

HMRC also publishes a list of named tax avoidance schemes and promoters. Check it, but remember that a company not being on the list does not mean it is compliant.

The “Too Good to Be True” Pay Test

Under compliant PAYE, part of the rate your agency pays goes on employment costs before you see any of it: the umbrella’s margin, employer National Insurance, employer pension and, for larger umbrellas, the Apprenticeship Levy. Income Tax, employee National Insurance and your own pension then come off your gross pay.

Example 1: a £300 day rate (illustrative, 2026/27)

Assumptions: £1,500 for a five-day week, paid weekly; tax code 1257L; National Insurance category A; a £25 weekly margin; holiday pay rolled up and included in gross pay; no Apprenticeship Levy (it applies only where the umbrella’s pay bill is over £3 million).

Pension: auto-enrolment at 3% employer and 5% employee on qualifying earnings between £120 and £967 a week, with the employee share taken from net pay under relief at source.

Employer costs: margin £25, employer National Insurance at 15% above £96 a week £176.56, employer pension £25.41. That leaves gross pay of £1,273.03.

Employee deductions: Income Tax £267.45, employee National Insurance at 8% between £242 and £967 £64.12, pension £33.88 (4% net, topped up to 5% by tax relief). Take-home pay is about £907.58, roughly 60% of the £1,500.

A scheme promising 80% to 85% would pay £1,200 to £1,275, about £292 to £367 a week more than compliant PAYE allows. That gap is almost always untaxed pay.

Your own figures will differ with your tax code, pension choices, margin and whether the levy applies. For a personal estimate, use HMRC’s tool to work out pay from an umbrella company.

How to Check Your Umbrella Payslip in 5 Minutes

HMRC’s guide to checking your payslip and Spotlight 71 suggest a handful of simple checks. Do them every time you start with a new umbrella, and again every few months.

  1. Compare your payslip with your Key Information Document. Check how gross pay was worked out from the assignment rate, with employer National Insurance, employer pension and holiday pay shown separately from your own deductions.
  2. Look at each deduction. Tax and National Insurance should be shown separately, not grouped with other items.
  3. Reconcile the net pay with your bank statement. If any extra payment arrives, find out who paid it, why, and what paperwork supports it.
  4. Check your personal tax account or the HMRC app. The employer name and pay reported to HMRC should match your payslips.
  5. Look up the umbrella on Companies House. Check its address, age and directors, and whether it has changed name recently.
Example 2: a reconciliation that fails

A worker on tax code 1257L and National Insurance category A has a weekly payslip showing gross pay of £500, tax of £51.62, National Insurance of £20.64 and net pay of £427.74. Their bank shows £427.74 from the umbrella, plus £520 from a different company described as a “loan”.

Their personal tax account shows pay of about £500 a week. The £520 has not been taxed or reported, which matches warning signs 2, 3 and 4.

What to Do If You Think You Are in a Scheme

Acting quickly matters, because the tax keeps building up while you stay in a scheme. HMRC’s guidance suggests these steps:

  1. Stop and keep everything: contracts, payslips, bank statements, emails and texts.
  2. Move to a compliant umbrella as soon as you can. HMRC “strongly advises” this in Spotlight 60.
  3. Contact HMRC by emailing CAGetHelpOutOfTaxAvoidance@hmrc.gov.uk to get help leaving the scheme and settling.
  4. Get independent advice from an accountant or tax adviser. If you are on a low income, TaxAid offers free help.
  5. Report the umbrella using HMRC’s online tax fraud form, adding the reference “TAC”, or call 0800 788 887. You can report anonymously.
Example 3: what a scheme can cost

A worker received £520 a week in untaxed “loans” for 40 weeks, a total of £20,800. If HMRC decides these were taxable employment income, extra Income Tax and possibly National Insurance can become due. The amount depends on the worker’s total taxable income, tax code, National Insurance category and earnings periods, and interest and penalties may be added.

If you cannot pay in one go, HMRC can agree a time to pay arrangement based on what you can afford. Settling early usually reduces interest and penalties. Be aware that HMRC cannot step in if a third party later demands repayment of a so-called loan, so get advice before signing anything about it.

You have had an HMRC letter about tax avoidance

HMRC uses real-time payroll data to spot workers who may be in schemes, and aims to write to them within about two months. A letter is not an accusation of fraud, but it should not be ignored. Read it carefully, note any deadline, compare it with your payslips and bank statements, and get independent advice.

Never accept “free help” from the umbrella or a firm it recommends to deal with HMRC for you. LITRG has clear guidance for workers who receive these letters.

What the April 2026 and 2027 Changes Mean for Workers

New PAYE rules have applied to labour supply chains that include umbrella companies since 6 April 2026. Generally, the recruitment agency that contracts to supply workers to the end client is responsible for making sure PAYE is operated correctly.

Where there is no agency, that responsibility falls on the end client, and the end client can also be responsible in some cases involving connected or overseas agencies. HMRC can recover unpaid PAYE from them even though the umbrella ran the payroll, according to the policy paper.

For workers, this means more checks by agencies and fewer rogue umbrellas in supply chains. Some agencies may move workers onto their own payroll instead. It does not make untaxed loans safe: if you knowingly receive pay outside PAYE, you can still be asked to pay the tax on it.

Separately, the government plans to bring umbrella companies within employment agency regulation, with the new Fair Work Agency expected to enforce it. This is planned, not yet in force, and no start date is confirmed here. Eternity Accountants covers the wider picture in its guide to IR35 and payroll changes in 2026.

Umbrella Workers and IR35

If you are genuinely employed by an umbrella company, you are taxed through PAYE as its employee, so IR35 does not apply to you the way it does to a contractor with a personal service company. IR35 and the off-payroll rules can still shape the wider supply chain and the decision to engage you through an umbrella. See Eternity’s guide to inside vs outside IR35.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign With an Umbrella

Each HMRC umbrella company warning points to one habit: ask questions and get the answers in writing. Before you sign, ask:

  • Will all of my pay go through PAYE?
  • What is your fee, and is it fixed?
  • Can I see a sample payslip and my Key Information Document?
  • Where is the company based?
  • Will I ever be asked to sign a loan, annuity or other extra agreement?

If the answers are vague, or you are pushed to sign quickly, treat that as a warning in itself and look for another umbrella.

Common Mistakes Umbrella Workers Make

MistakeWhat to do instead
Trusting an “HMRC-approved” claimRemember HMRC never approves umbrella companies
Ignoring extra payments into your bankTreat any payment outside your payslip as a red flag
Never checking your personal tax accountCompare it with your payslips every few months
Signing extra agreements without reading themRefuse anything you do not understand and get advice
Waiting after an HMRC letterRespond, check your records and get advice quickly
Using the umbrella’s “free help” with HMRCUse an independent adviser instead
Assuming an umbrella not on HMRC’s named list is compliantRun your own payslip and bank checks anyway

HMRC Umbrella Company Warning: FAQs

Does HMRC approve umbrella companies?

No. HMRC never approves umbrella companies or tax avoidance schemes. Any company that claims HMRC approval is showing a warning sign.

Is it illegal to work through an umbrella company?

No. Most umbrella companies are compliant and run all pay through PAYE. The problem is the minority that pay part of your wages as untaxed loans or other payments.

What is disguised remuneration?

It is pay for your work that is labelled as something else, such as a loan, annuity or bonus, to avoid Income Tax and National Insurance. HMRC treats it as taxable employment income.

How do I know if my umbrella company is compliant?

Check that your payslip matches your Key Information Document and your bank, that all pay comes from one payer through PAYE, and that your personal tax account shows the same figures.

Can I be taxed if my umbrella company did not pay?

If your umbrella deducted tax through PAYE but did not pass it on, HMRC can pursue the agency or end client. If you received untaxed payments outside PAYE, you can be asked to pay the tax yourself.

What should I do if I get a letter from HMRC about tax avoidance?

Do not ignore it. Check your payslips and bank statements, note any deadline, get independent advice and consider leaving the scheme and contacting HMRC.

How do I report an umbrella company to HMRC?

Use HMRC’s online tax fraud form and add the reference “TAC”, or call 0800 788 887. You can report anonymously.

What is mini umbrella company fraud?

It is where workers are spread across many small, short-lived companies to claim reliefs and avoid paying tax. Frequent unexplained changes of employer name can be a sign.

Can an umbrella company legally pay part of my wages as a loan?

Pay for your work is employment income, whatever it is called. HMRC says arrangements that pay wages as loans or similar to avoid tax are tax avoidance, and the tax remains due.

Who is responsible for unpaid PAYE under the April 2026 rules?

Generally the recruitment agency that supplies you to the end client. Where there is no agency, the end client is responsible, and in some cases involving connected or overseas agencies it can be too.

Does an HMRC warning letter mean I have committed tax fraud?

No. It means HMRC thinks you may be in a tax avoidance arrangement. Do not ignore it: check your records, get independent advice and respond.

Can I check my umbrella pay in my personal tax account?

Yes. Your personal tax account and the HMRC app show the employer and pay reported to HMRC, which you can compare with your payslips.

Final Verdict on the HMRC Umbrella Company Warning

The message behind every HMRC umbrella company warning is simple: if your take-home pay looks better than normal PAYE allows, the tax is probably being avoided, and you may be the one who pays for it later. Check your payslip, bank and personal tax account regularly, and act quickly if anything does not match.

MTDFix can check your umbrella pay records and help you deal with HMRC.

Worried about your umbrella payslips or an HMRC letter?
Get your pay records checked by an accountant
✓ Payslips, bank and HMRC records compared ✓ Help responding to HMRC letters ✓ Self Assessment if you need to put things right
Fixed fees agreed before we start.
Why you can trust this guide

Written by the MTDFix Editorial Team and reviewed by Shamayun Chowdhury, a chartered management accountant (ACMA, MAAT) with more than 15 years’ UK practice experience. Based on HMRC’s Spotlights 60, 64 and 71, HMRC’s payslip and “Spot the signs” guidance, and HMRC’s policy papers on the umbrella company market, as at 22 November 2026. Pay examples use 2026/27 rates and illustrative figures, recalculated in full.

We do not name, recommend or accuse any umbrella company. This is general information, not personal tax or legal advice.

MTDFix is a trading name of Major Accountancy Ltd. Eternity Accountants, linked in this guide, is a sister accountancy firm.

Written by the Editorial Team · Reviewed by ✔ Reviewed by a qualified accountant

Written by

MTDFix Editorial Team

The team writes plain-English Making Tax Digital and UK tax guides for sole traders, landlords and limited company directors. Every guide is researched from GOV.UK and HMRC sources and checked by a qualified accountant before publication.

UK tax researchGOV.UK & HMRC sourcesPlain-English guides
Shamayun Chowdhury, ACMA, chartered management accountant in Leicester

Reviewed by

Shamayun Chowdhury

BA (Hons), MSc, ACMA, CMA, CIPFA (Affil), MAAT, AATQB · Senior Accountant · Leicester

Shamayun is a chartered management accountant (ACMA) and a full member of AAT with more than 15 years of UK practice. He helps sole traders, landlords and limited companies with Self Assessment, VAT and Making Tax Digital, and lectures in accounting at Nottingham Trent University. He reviewed this guide against current GOV.UK and HMRC rules before it was published.

Chartered management accountantSelf AssessmentVAT & MTD15+ years’ UK practice

How we checked this guide

Written by the MTDFix Editorial Team and reviewed by Shamayun Chowdhury, a chartered management accountant (ACMA, MAAT) with more than 15 years’ UK practice experience. Every rate, threshold and deadline was checked against official GOV.UK and HMRC guidance, and against UK legislation where relevant, before publishing. We check it again whenever HMRC changes its guidance.

Disclaimer: This guide is general information, not personal tax, financial or pension advice. Speak to an accountant about your own circumstances. We review this guide every 12 months, or sooner if HMRC guidance changes.